Let me take you back to a vague memory from my childhood. I've been dragged to some kind of dinner party being held by a coworker of my mother. The dude in question is not much of a gamer at all although I do remember him having a large music CD collection which stuck out in my mind because at the time I was interested in that Monster Rancher game on PS1 where you could put other CDs in the PS1 to get monsters. I looked at his music CDs and was like "wow, imagine all the shit you'd get from a collection like this". To his credit, he tried to relate to me a little bit by telling me about the one game he was familiar with, Deus Ex. I hadn't heard of it at the time and the way he described it to me was "its a shooter but you have to manage your inventory. Pick a big gun and not carry much stuff, or a smaller gun so you can use more medkits and other tools. Also you can pick skills like hacking and swimming. You can be stealthy or go all guns blazing".
Being the non-gamer that he was he didn't have the vocabulary to give Deus Ex a more succinct description but he was describing what we would know today as the "immersive sim" and off the back of that conversation he would allow me to borrow the game and it would become one of my faves of all time. Other examples of Immersive Sims if you google it are games such as Dishonored, System Shock 2, Cruelty Squad, Prey, Ultima Underworld and Pathalogic. All games that have interconnecting systems and player choice, games that try to simulate an actual living breathing world that reacts to things that the player does and choices the player makes. To give you an example of just how much I love these kind of games, there's a game called Blood West which I initially ignored because I have very little interest in the wild west as a setting in fiction, but as soon as someone told me it was an immersive sim, I bought it right away. At time of writing this post, it's not been played yet, though. So don't go misunderstanding the title of this post, I'm not here to shit on the genre itself, these games are great (except for System Shock 2, that can go fuck itself, another post for another day), it's only the genre title that the unwashed gamer masses have given it that I have a problem with
The problem I have here is that the name doesn't fucking tell you anything because it basically describes every game ever. We know what type of game its describing now because we're all so used to it but every time I hear it, it sounds like nails on chalkboard to my brain. Most games that have ever existed are trying to immerse you in something and most games are trying to simulate something. Ridge Racer is attempting to immerse you in the act of racing sports cars around funky looking tracks and is simulating the act of driving but you'd be called a moron if you called that an Immersive Sim. Final Fantasy 10 is trying to immerse the player in the world of Spira and is simulating going on an adventure to stop a big fish from destroying the world. Is that an Immersive Sim then? No, dumbass, its a JRPG. Power Wash Simulator is trying to immerse you in the act of having your own power washing company and is simulating power washing, does that count? No.
The genre title is so dumb that a lot of players can't even decide what is and isn't an immersive sim sometimes. I've heard for a long time that Thief is an immersive sim but when I googled that I got hit with a reddit page on an immersive sim subreddit saying that it doesn't count. A similar story with the game Bioshock which I had heard some people call an immersive sim because the player has the ability to approach different parts of the game differently depending on their loadout but somehow that doesn't make the cut either. I mentioned Ultima Underworld earlier but what makes that an immersive sim opposed to just a regular dungeon crawler? It's such a wishy-washy term that describes most games so broadly that these arguments appear quite often in forums and social media.
You may think you sound intelligent by saying that you enjoy "immersive sims" but really you're no better than the non-gaming coworker from my childhood memories. I don't have a solution to this problem, I don't know if there is a catch all term you can apply to this style of game and have it make sense. Maybe the continued use of Immersive Sim is the best solution despite my hatred for how stupid it is, it's been in use for so long that we at least know what kind of game the person is talking about when they use it. I wish we had something better but maybe the sad conclusion to this dumb rant is that there's no way to fix it. Feel free to let me know if you have any ideas.
.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment